AU3969578A - Corrosion control process - Google Patents
Corrosion control processInfo
- Publication number
- AU3969578A AU3969578A AU39695/78A AU3969578A AU3969578A AU 3969578 A AU3969578 A AU 3969578A AU 39695/78 A AU39695/78 A AU 39695/78A AU 3969578 A AU3969578 A AU 3969578A AU 3969578 A AU3969578 A AU 3969578A
- Authority
- AU
- Australia
- Prior art keywords
- lead
- carbonate
- water
- corrosion
- results
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Pending
Links
Classifications
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C02—TREATMENT OF WATER, WASTE WATER, SEWAGE, OR SLUDGE
- C02F—TREATMENT OF WATER, WASTE WATER, SEWAGE, OR SLUDGE
- C02F5/00—Softening water; Preventing scale; Adding scale preventatives or scale removers to water, e.g. adding sequestering agents
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C23—COATING METALLIC MATERIAL; COATING MATERIAL WITH METALLIC MATERIAL; CHEMICAL SURFACE TREATMENT; DIFFUSION TREATMENT OF METALLIC MATERIAL; COATING BY VACUUM EVAPORATION, BY SPUTTERING, BY ION IMPLANTATION OR BY CHEMICAL VAPOUR DEPOSITION, IN GENERAL; INHIBITING CORROSION OF METALLIC MATERIAL OR INCRUSTATION IN GENERAL
- C23F—NON-MECHANICAL REMOVAL OF METALLIC MATERIAL FROM SURFACE; INHIBITING CORROSION OF METALLIC MATERIAL OR INCRUSTATION IN GENERAL; MULTI-STEP PROCESSES FOR SURFACE TREATMENT OF METALLIC MATERIAL INVOLVING AT LEAST ONE PROCESS PROVIDED FOR IN CLASS C23 AND AT LEAST ONE PROCESS COVERED BY SUBCLASS C21D OR C22F OR CLASS C25
- C23F11/00—Inhibiting corrosion of metallic material by applying inhibitors to the surface in danger of corrosion or adding them to the corrosive agent
- C23F11/08—Inhibiting corrosion of metallic material by applying inhibitors to the surface in danger of corrosion or adding them to the corrosive agent in other liquids
- C23F11/18—Inhibiting corrosion of metallic material by applying inhibitors to the surface in danger of corrosion or adding them to the corrosive agent in other liquids using inorganic inhibitors
Landscapes
- Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Organic Chemistry (AREA)
- Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
- Hydrology & Water Resources (AREA)
- Environmental & Geological Engineering (AREA)
- Water Supply & Treatment (AREA)
- Inorganic Chemistry (AREA)
- Materials Engineering (AREA)
- Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
- Metallurgy (AREA)
- Preventing Corrosion Or Incrustation Of Metals (AREA)
Description
WETWfOLLAR~
[0 LAR \1FORm 4.
Patents Act 195 -19
CONVENITION APPLICATION R A PATENT WE WE gPPKorati.o org~anized u.nder (Use BLOCK Iters)
w. f D la ae U I. S:of. Tw Jy iaPa 1 NqW ok.tt ofNw ok Unie
here~by apply for the grant of a Patent for an invention entitled K FOR A.POLi g.QJI.FQ.L PQCESS E WATER DIS'T.RB.UTIN SSEM .0
xlich is described in the accompanying complete specification. This application is a Convention
pplication and is based on t1~e'application numbered for a patent or similar
protection made in dP4Stts
n.
*address for aiervice is Cre f SANDER SMI TH .Patent, Attorneys, Our g. V tra Australia.
Dated this 7t day of. TEMBER 98. CHURCH DWIGHT CO., INC. TO: THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
(Signature) BY: SANDERCOCK, SMITH BEADLE This, form must be aceompanleil by a complete specification (Form 10 and a true copy) and the appropriate lodgment I'em The address for service slated In this form must be an address In Australia.
16318/75 16318/75A=K2Nw Government Printer, Canberra
'VPM AUSTRALIA PATENTS ACT 1952
Insert name of In support of the application m~ade by -CHURCH DWIGHT CO INC, applicant. Insert title of for a patent foran invention entitled: CORROSION CONTROL PROCESO3 FOR A Invention. PO'PAlf-E WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM Insert full name(s) l./we Duncan Dunbar Dwight. 3 Crest Acre Court. Summit. 07901. New and address(es) of prson(s) making dclaration. If applicant a company person must be authorlsad to make declaration. do solemnly and sincerely declare as follows:
*Delete alterrnatiqas OR I am authorized by the abovementioned applicant to make this declaration on its which do not apply behalf. 2. (FxxL4MIKKtf MgMVp~kf~ tjV Insert namels, and OR JAES WTT.r.TAM PATTERZSONxa US.A. citizen, addiass(es) of actual 1540 0 1 tate_-,treet, Chicago, State of Illinois, inventor(s). 11nii-p States of_-America
is/ape the actual inventor(o* of the invention and the facts upon which the applicant(o) is/wfe entitled *lntert details of to make the application are as follows.- entitlement to apply, The said CHURCH DWIGHT CO. .INC., is the assignee of the :.tj Applicant is said JAMES W.PATTERSON by a Deed of Assignment. a assigr*a of inventor(s)
3. Tii basic applP"~tion(&) as defined by Section 141 of the Act was/waoe made in the follow- ing country oF-reopi4tes on the following date(s)4 by the following applicantwe 'in U.S.A. on May 18, 1978 _19 ,DelgtV.3 and 411f by James W.Patterson appli~aton non" in convention. Otherwise insert by 'Adetalls of basic in application(s). by in on __19
by Sa 0 4. The basic applicationtts) referred to in paragraph 3 of this Declaration was/Wefe the first application(e) made in a Convention country in respect of the invention the ,dbject of the application.
Piece andl date of DecI0adat New York, New Yorkthis_____day of August 24, 19 78 .Signature. United States of America
TO: The Commissioner of Patents, Australia oa K "2 o
(11) AU-A 1-39,695/78
(12) PATENT SPECIFICATION ABSTRACT (19) AU
(21) 39,695/78 (22) 8.9.78 (24) 18.5.78 (31) 907280 (32) 18.5.78 (33) US (43) 13.3.80 (51)2 0-23F 9/00 C23F 11/18 (54) Corrosion control process (71) Church Dwight Co., Inc. (72) Patterson, J.W. (74) SA (57) Claim 1. A process for controlling corrosion in a potab.e water distribution system including lead-containing con- duits which comprises adding a water-soluble carbonate source to the drinking water distributed by said system in the amount required to pasivate the lead-containing conduits of said system and maintaining the pH of the pot- able water withinsaid system at a pH of 7.5 to
~ND 9.2
Form PATENTS ACT 1952-1973
COMf"PLETE SPECIFICATION (ORIGINAL) FOR OFFICE USE Class lot CI:
Application Number: Lodged:
*"Uhplete Specification-Lodged: SO Accente~d 0@ 0 0 Published: 0 0 r 0000 *.&iority: 0* S J 00 f~p~ go 0 *4 S C S I.; Related Art:
40 S S 0@ TO BE COMPLETED BY APPLICANT t'~ne of Applicant: CHURCH DWIGHT CO., INC.
Address of Applicant: United States of America.
(>Actual Inventor: JAMES W. PATTERSON
Address for Service: Care of SANDERCOCK, SMITH BEADLE, *Patent Attorneys, 203 Riversdale Road, Box 410-) Hawthorn, 3122, Victoria, Australi a.
Compl ete Specification for the invention entitled: CORROSION CONTROL PROCESS FOR A POTABLE WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM
'-The following statement is a full description of this invention, including the best method of performing it known to ya:- *us: *Nte Tuhe description isto be typed indouble spacing,, pica type face, inan area not exceeding 250mm in depth anid 160 mm in width, on tough white paper of good quality and it isto be inserted inside this form.
111r7 F. 0. Atkinson, Govemment Printer, Canberra
-lA-
BACKGROUND 0? TH~E INVENTION Lead pipe and lead based solders have been in service for many years in water distribution systems. The lead pipe is employed primarily for service and residential lines and its use is prevalent in many parts of Europe and North America. A study in the early twentieth century, encompassing 41 states, revealed that 4a percent of the more than 500 water distribution systems surveyed contained lead lines. The expected service life of lead pipe is extremely long, and it is probable that many of the original lead lines installed in the 'Un.5,ted States remain in 000 15 place today. Lead service lines continue to be 0 installed in this country, for instance, Chicago, and 00 lead solders are also widely employed. 000 When systems containing lead components are 0 0 used to distribute corrosive water, lead levels in the 20 water at the tap can greatly exceed the U. S. EPA *0 0 S interim primary drinking water standard of 0.05 mg/l. In one recent study of 16 separate New England water distribution systems, twelve of the systems exceeded the lead standard, for onf more samples taken (Karalekas et al, Conference, New England Water Works Association, Sept. 1977). Over 90 percent of the samples recently collected from one town in Vermont exceeded the lead standard. These excessive lead levels result primarily through the corrosive action of water on lead pipes. Lead solders, however, have also been implicated as a source of lead in corrosive water supplies.
k
Typically, corrosive waters are low in pH, dissolved solids and alkali.nity.
Parameter Bennington. Boston Seattle PH 4.9 6.3 5.4 Dissolved Solids, mg/i 20 30 28 Alkalinity, mg/i as CaCO 3 1 4 4 Dissolved Oxygen, mg/i 11.6 10.6
S. S Factors whirch influence corrosion rates include tempera- 0*e C
*0*S ture, pH, alkalinity and hardness. The results of a S S C. .t 0 10 comprehensive British survey indicate that the amount @6
o 6 S S and length of lead pipe present are also significant factors; "Lead in Drinking Water," Pollution Paper No. 0* C C C. 12, Department of the Environment, London, 1977. The OS CS C 6 concentrations of dissolved oxygen and dissolved C solids such as chloride ion also appear to influence corrosion, although the relative importance of these 4~ C. two parameters have not been fully difined. Others 0 C *5
S. have cited the influence of water velocity, which is C*S important both in determining the micro-structure of OSOO 20 any protective coating formed on the pipe interior, as 00 C. S well as on erosion of corrosion products formed at the pipe wall. C
*6 6 Lead is well recognized and regarded as an S. active and cumulative toxicant, and the distribution of corrosive water through lead pipe can constitute a serious health hazard for the consumer. This property of lead pipe has been known for more than twenty cen- turies, and in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, there were in fact numerous reported instances of illness or death from drinking water delivered through lead pipes.
The presence of high levels of body lead has been well documented in the literature and related to hyperactivity, decreased intelligence levels, hyperten- sion, mental retardation, learning disabilities and renal insufficiency. In summary, excessive lead in domestic water supplies has a harmful effect on health and well-being, particularly that of children and young adults. The 1976 U. S. Environmental Prctection Agency interim primary drinking water standard for lead is 0.05 mg/l. .c Due to the adverse effect of lead on physical, mental, and neurological health, serious consideration is *currently underway to lower that limit to 0.025 mg/l (Federal Register, July 11, 1977). It is likely that a 15 large majority of the waters distributed through systems incorporating lead components would violate this lower standard. Corrosion is a long-standing and serious problem in many municipal and private water distribu- 20 tion systems. In 1976 it was suggested that nearly *half of the 100 largest cities in the United States distribute corrosive water. Many of the older munici- .palities in the nation have a large number of lead service lines. A service line, typically 30-100 feet in length, connects the street main to the household plumbing system. (aters capable of corroding lead lines also attack other metallic components of a water distribu- tion system, including copper, iron and galvanized piping. Thus, increments in many metal constituents above background source water levels are normally observed at the tap. These metal increments can exceed recommended drinking water criteria, and indi- cate corrosion rates which significantly reduce the useful life of the distribution system.
i r
Several methods of controlling corrosion have been suggested. For example, in waters of moderate or greater hardness, corrosion control has classically b~een based upon pH adjustment to provide and maintain a protective calcium carbonate coating on the interior pipe surface. However, in waters of low hardness, such as occur consistently along the eastern seaboar4d, and in the southeastern and northwestern portions of the United States, this option is not available. Other alternatives reported for corrosion control include pH adjustment alone, the addition of commercial corrosion inhibiters typically containing *0 phosphate or silicate salts, or pH adjustment plus *~*addition of the commercial inhibiters. As a result of one extensive study in Boston, it has been reported that pH adjustment alone rediuced lead corrosion product levels; however, since about one-third of the samples collected continued to exceed the interim primary standard for lead, pH adj ustment alone was not con- sidered to provide effective corrosion control. The 0 0
corrosion upon addition of a zinc phosphate salt to the Bloston water supply (Karalekas et al, Conference, 0 New England Water works Association, Sept. 1977). It has also been recognized that chemical addi- 4* Of* tives, for corrosion control, such as zinc and silicate a*O compounds, have been more successful with water for industry than with domestic water supplies, due in part to the higher chemical additive levels allowable in the former case. Such chemicals are often expensive, and can also be hazardous to handle. Another approach to corrosion control has been suggested, based upon the low theoretical solubility of lead-carbonate salts at pH near 8.5, and results from field surveys which suggest an inverse correlation between water pH and carb~onate alkcalinity, a,-d water corrosivity to lead pipe ("Lead in Drinking water," smpra) BRIEF DESCRIPTI*ON OF~ THE INVENTION S Z have discovered that reduction and control of lead corrosion in drinking water distribution systems is achieved by a combination of appropriate pH adjust- ment and carbonate supplementation and that there exists a certain inter-relationship between pH and carbonate content. The optimum pH appears to be between about pH 7.5 and about pH 9.0 depending upon the carbonate-level, and a minimum carbonate alkalinity :concentration of 20 mg/l. measured as CaCO 3 although sue. higher and lower values may be indicated depending upon the parameters of the water being treated. Although I o*do not wish to be bound to any specific theory, it appears that this pr'ncedure causes a protective basic carbonate layer to form on the pipe interior, depending u.pon the metal content of the pipe. For instance, a lead pipe would be invested with a lead carbonate protective layer. 00 0 5BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS eg Figure 1 is a graph illustrating pH equilibrium *:so conditions for lead passivation, corrosion and immunity in water; Figure 2 is a graph illustrating pH equilibrium conditions at a one molar carbonate concentration for lead passivation; Figure 3 is a graph showing the calculated solubility of lead water with and without the presence ofE carbonate; Figure 4 is a graph showing corrosion water at 9days for lead and galvanic lead-copper coupons;
Figure 5 is a graph comparing the results of lead content at 9 and 30 days exposure to lead coupons; Figure 5 is a graph illustrating the results of lead pipe corrosion tests, as a percent of control calculated against time in days for caustic, bicarbon- ate and caustic plus bicarbonate treatments; and Figure 7 is a graph reporting corrosion results on lead over a period of time at a constant pH and carbonate alkalinity.
The invention provides a solution to the o*
serious problem of lead corrosion in drinking water that exists in many areas of the world, typically in relatively soft, acidic water. According to the disclosed process, a protective metal carbonate coating or. film is provided on the interior of the oo water distribution system. More specifically, corro- sion passivation is achieved by forming a metal-carbon- ate salt film of lcw solubility the film being formed as the metallic corrosion products react electrochemic- ally with the water borne carbonate. The resulting film protects the reacting metal surface from the aqueous bulk phase. The identity of.the metal species
o. S of the carbonate layer depends upon the metal content of the pipe on which the layer is electrochemically formed and deposited. As indicated, the metal species of current concern is lead, however, the corresponding carbonate is formed on the interior of copper, iron, steel and galvanized (predominantly zinc) pipes. Corrosion control is achieved by adding to drinking water carefully controlled amounts of carbon- ate, such as sodium bicarbonate, in conjunction with
*adjusting the pH1 of the drinking water within a-predeter- mined range. A convenient base is sodium hydroxide or lime. Based upon. the following description and guide- lines the skilled operator will select the proper pH range and carbonate content necessary to achieve the desired metal corrosion control. of the several factors involved, the more significant include the pH, dissolved solids, alkalinity and dissolved oxygen con-- tent of the drinking water being treated in conjunction with the identity and concentration of the undesirable metal ion or ions emanAti~ig_ from the involved water distribution system. 4 *0 Experience has showli that an optimum pH1 appears g~e Cto be in the range of between about pH 7.5 and about 0eeC 00 1 9.0 and preferably between about pH1 8.0 and about pH 8.5, and a minimum carbonate alkalinity concentration of about 20 m/I, measured as CaCO 3 the two parameters 6 being directly interrelated. C Iz a given corrosive water distribution system, there are several methods for establishing the required metal carbonate film. For example, an initial high carbonate dose may be used to accelerate the film o cc formation, followed by lower maintenance dosages. coo Another approach is to begin with low carbonate levels and gradually increase the carbonate level until posi- tive results are obtained, In either instance, the formed protective film must be permanently maintained through continued carbonate addition and pH1 control. Termination of the-carbonate supplementation results in gradual reversion to the active corrosive condition. Proper control of carbonate level and pH are essential to the establishment and maintenance of the protective coating. The following data are concerned primarily with lead due to the current awareness of the serious health problems it poses, however it should be understood that the process of our invention applies equally as well to other corrosive metals in a typical water distribution system including copper, iron, galvanized (ainc) and steel. Certain theoretical aspects of the present invention are now considered. Corrosion is the destruc- tion of a metal, usually by electrochemical reaction, with its environment. The tendency toward corrosion is expressed by the relative electrochemical potential as compared to the standard hydrogen electrode. This potential is a measure of the oxidation and reduction *J characteristics of the interface between the metal and 0* the water, and the relative potentials of two different 6 0 15 metals determine which metal has the greater tendency e0 towards corrosion. The rate of corrosion is dependent @00 upon each metal, and environmental parameters including ionic components, dissolved oxygen, dissolved carbon 0 dioxide, temperature, impurities in the metal, and flow rate of the water. Corrosion results in the flow of electric current between anodic and cathodic areas on 0 the metal surface. In almost all forms of pipe corro- sion, the metal goes into solution at the anodic 0 areas, upon oxidation. Electrons liberated at anodic 25 (oxidation) sites flow through the metal to cathodic S 0 sites where they become involved in a second (reduc- tion) chemical reaction. This may typically be the reduction of oxygen, to yield hydroxyl ions. 0 Figure 1 illustrates pH-equilibrium conditions for lead passivation, corrosion and immunity in water at a concentration of 10 6 molar for the soluble species according to calculated equilibrium equations. See Pourbaix "Atlas Electrochemical Equilibrium in Aqueous Solutions", National Association of Corrosion Engineers, 1974. Normal water conditions fall between
~ss Himv W i
T -9-
the two dashed lines. Metallic lead is shown to be theoretically immune from corrosion only at potential values below -0.30 (and pH below although active corrosion is in actuality often observed within the perimeter of this immune zone. At high potential and pH values, the metallic surface is protected from corrosion by formation of an impervious and adherent coating of PbO 2 This phenomena is termed passivation, and occurs upon deposition of any protective coating, sach as calcium carbonate. At intermediate potential, across the full pH range, active corrosion occurs with forma- I i 0@ tion of either soluble Pb 2 o: HPbO 2 or a solid corro- sion product. The predicted solid product is red lead I• oxide. However, lead hydroxide is initially formed as r 0 an intermediate. Lead hydroxide is highly soluble and kc I o~ lacks adherent properties, and its erosion in flowing I II systems is responsible for the turbid appearance of I corrosive water contacted with lead pipe, while its 2 00 00 00* 0 solubility is evidenced by the high concentrations of eOSC soluble lead reported. s i" Carbonate alkalinity also influences the system, go thus in aqueous systems containing soluble carbonate, S* 000 insoluble lead carbonate salts form in the intermediate pH region between the domains of immunity and passiva- 'i o tion as illustrated in Figure 1. Figure 2 shows that passivation results through the formation of very insol- 0 uble lead carbonate compounds on the corroding lead 0S oeC C CO surface as shown below:
7T---ll
pH Region Solid Phase Low Lead Carbonate, PbCO 3 t. Intermediate Lead HydroxyCarbonate, Pb 3 (CO3 )2(OH)2
5 These salts perform two functions; by adherence to the C
metallic surface they protect the metal from its corro- sive environment, and the carbonate solid phase limits the lead solubility and therefore the soluble lead concentration at the water pipe interface. The pres- ence of these salts incrementally reduces the soluble lead level at increasing carbonate concentration as C. shown in Figure 3. In the figure, line represents S S S S.S the lead hydroxide solubility at zero carbonate concen- SS tration while line represents the solubility at 15 10-3. 2 molar concentration of carbonate. As illus- trated by this figure at any given carbonate concen- tration, there is a pH value of minimum lead carbonate C solubility. At any constant pH, there is also a point of minimum lead carbonate solubility corresponding to 20 a specific carbonate concentration. Soo The beneficial aspects of moderate naturally 9 occurring carbonate alkalinity in controlling corrosion have been recognized for many years, and this method of corrosion control, by formation of the metal-carbonate salt film, protects the metal surface from the aqueous phase. The regions of lead corrosion and passivation for water without and with carbonate are shown in Figures 1 and 2, respectively. By comparison of these two diagrams, it is apparent that the formation of a lead-carbonate salt film results in passivation protec- tion across a broad range of potential and pH values.
-1i-
The invention.will be further elucidated by the following examples which are illustrative of the pro- cess of the present invention. DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS Water used for these studies was collected from metropolitan Boston's Wachusetts Reservoir. This water is typical of many soft corrosive waters. Its chemical analysis is surmmarized in the following table: TABLE 1 .Constitiient Concentration 6o Mg/l *Meg/l Carbon Dioxide (as C0 2 1.2 Total Carbonate (as CaCO 3 6.0 0.12 0* Chloride 8.3 0.24 00 00 15 Sulfate 8.0 0.16 Calcium 4.0 0.20 Magnesium 0.7 0.06 Sodium 5.5 0.24 Potassium 0.8 0.02 Color units 12 0 0 Turbidity 0
00Q *0 Stm of Cations 0.52 meg/l #0
Sum of Anions 0.52 meg/l *0*o In some experiments, distilled water was reconstituted 0• 25 to simulate Boston water. Examples 1-8; Coupon Tests In this series of tests, lead coupons were in- cubated in water supplemented to various carbonate levels for 9 to 30 days, under static conditions in sealed containers. Initial pH values of 7.0 and were investigated. The primary purpose of this phase of the experimental work was to gain practical information concerning the concentrations of carbonate required for "passivating" and "maintenance" doses in corroding lead systems. Sodium hydroxide was used to adjust pH, and sodium bicarbonate employed for carbon- ate addition. In a parallel test, coupons of lead bonded to copper for galvanic corrosion studies were also incu- bated for 9 and 30 day periods, at carbonate levels ranging from 0 to 100 mg/l carbonate alkalinity as CaCO 3 It has been reported in some communities, such as Vancouver, British Columbia, that lead soldered joints in copper lines constituted a significant source of galvanic lead corrosion. Nine day corrosion results for the "lead only" and "galvanic" systems are summarized in Figure 4. Highest soluble lead levels were observed in the Sabsence of carbonate, with the corrosion results for the galvanic coupons bei.g much higher than those for the "lead only" systems. At the lowest supplemental carbonate level tested (14 mg/l as CaC0 3 a signifi- cant reduction in corrosion resulted for all systems. Lowest lead levels were observed over the full range of added carbonate for the lead coupons incubated at an initial pH 8.0. For the pH 7.0 lead system, there was a significant decrease in soluble lead with increasing Scarbonate alkalinity. Upon Lontinued exposure (to thirty days) even better results were obtained on the pH 7.0 system as shown in Figure 5. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of carbonate supplementa- tion with the appropriate pH adjustment in controlling lead corrosion. The following table summarizes the lead coupon test results at 9 and 30 days of incubation.
TA13LM 2
Initial Values Nine-Day Results Thirty-Day Results Example pH CA pH CA Pb pH CA Pb
1 7.0 0.0 9.15 0.00 1.21' 9.59 0.00 6.39 2 13.7 7.03 5.4 0.45 9.10 3.8 0.12 3 47,1 7.39 41.4 0.36 8.46 38.9 0.15 4 97.1 7.19 92.9 0.20 7.45 91.9 0.12
8.0 0.0 9.61 0.00 3.60 9.57 0.00 1.82 6 14.2 8.75 6.3 0.11 9.02 8.1 0.08 7 47.1 8.50 43.4 0.11 9.09 41.8 0.11 8 97.1 8.27 91.3 0.11 8.68 94.7 0.10
CA Carbonate Alkalinity as mg/l CaCO 3 Pb Soluble Lead Concentration, mg/l
00 00 so• 0 "0 S.D S.00 S 0a 05Q S S~ *0 4 0 0: 00 0 0* 0 0 0 *0oo 0m 0e 00••
TAflME 2
Initial Values Nine-Day Results Thirty-Day Results EFxampl e pH CA pH CA Pb pH CA Pb
1 7.0 0.0 9.15 0.00 1.35 9.59 0.00 6.39 2 13.7 7.03 5.4 0.45 9.10 3.8 0.12 3 47Al 7.39 41.4 0.36 8.46 38.9 0.15 4 97.1 7.19 92.9 0.20 7.45 91.9 0.12
8.0 0.0 9.61 0.00 3.60 9.57 0.00 1.82 6 14.2 8.75 6.3 0.11 9.02 8.1 0.08 7 47.1 8.50 43.4 0.11 9.09 41.8 0.11 8 97.1 8.27 91.3 0.11 8.68 94.7 01
CA Carbonate Alkalinity as mg/i CaCO 3 Pb =Soluble Lead Concentration, rng/l
6 00 @0 *0 *0 *3 @6 6 0 *0 SS 0 0 0 6 6 *0 600 0 0 0.0 0 S @5 0 000 0 060 0 6.0 6* .66 *6 06 6. 066 0 60 *6 90
In all test systems, pH increased as a result of the electrochemical reduction of oxygen. Highest pH and greatest measured yield of lead corrosion products was observed in the absence of carbonate. Slight supplemnental addition of carbonate, as sodium bicarbon- ate, greatly reduced lead corrosion, as evidenced by small increases in both the soluble lead level and pH. Except at the lowest initial carbonate level investi- gated, carbonate remained essentially constant through- out the test- period. For each lead analysis of the above table, results. include the "burst" of lead resulting for the *9 .4 9 initial corrosic)n when the passivation film is formed. 0* 9 *94 0 This burst is a continuing phenomenon in corroding S. 40 09 15 systems, where passivating films do not form. 0S *9 6 Examples A-C and' Shorft-term Lead Pipe Studies 6 *0*9 A fifteen foot length of half-inch lead pipe 0S
.9 @0 Ien from service in Boston's distribution system was 0O 9 94 -it into eight 20 inch lengths, and one end of each 6 0 dpe segment was permanently sealed. All pipe sections, employed as replicate controls, were filled on a daily 40 basis with untreated water until the initial randomness *4 9 9O of "24 hour corrosion rates" in individual sections .4 4. *00 rahed about ±20 percent of the mean corrosion rate. 90.* 25 This required approximately three weeks. The caustic 04 44 4 used was sodium hydroxide. Subsequently, each of 4 systems, described in .9 the following table, were tested, in duplicate sections 4* 9
of pipe. The experimental regimen employed was as follows: duplicate pipes were completely filled with each of the four test solutions, placed upright in a holder, and capped; after 24 hours, each pipe length was inverted for analysis of pH, alkalinity, and total lead (upon acidification) by atomic absorp- tion spectrophotometry; each pipe section was.
immediately refilled with its respective test solution and recapped for another 24 hour exposure period. This procedure was repeated daily for 60 day i. TABLE 3
Example Condition
A Control B Caustic Addition for pH adjustment to initial pH C Sodium bicarbonate addition for J.0 carbonate adjustment to initial mg/l as CaC03 S. 9 Caustic plus sodium bicarbonate addition (pH 8.5 and carbonate S* *alkalinity 20 mg/l as CaC0 3
15 Results are summarized in Figure 6, where 24 hour corrosion rates are plotted as a function of time for each of the systems studied. The 24 hour corrosion Srate of the untreated control remained constant at 0.5 mg/l (total lead) per day throughout the day period of the study, without any evidence of passi- vation. Typically, static laboratory tests overesti- mate actual field corrosion rates, and experience indicates that this laboratory rate is significantly greater than the 1976 average actually attained in 4 0 25 Boston's untreated distribution system. It was thus considered more meaningful to plot the experimental corrosion rates of Figure 6 as percentages of the con- trol rate, rather than as actual lead concentrations. It will be observed that a4- three corrosion -control techniques resulted in reduced lead concentra- tions. During the first 10-day period, pH adjustment and carbonate supplementation each yielded similar reductions in total lead of about 75 percent, with the combination treatment of pH adjustment plus carbonate ii**.
r
16-
addition resulting in an 85 percent reduction in corrosion at ten days. However, within two weeks after the start of corrective treatment, Example B, involving pH adjustment alone, began giving evidence of serious and repeated "unloading" of particulate lead corrosion products. From a public health viewpoint, pH adjust- ment in the absence of sufficient carbonate alkalinity may result in a more insidious type of corrosion than that accompanying no treatment at all. The reasons for this are that individuals may periodically ingest large slugs of toxic lead when non-adherent Ph(OH) 2 "sloughs off." Also, the results of intermittent, monitoring surveys will not necessarily reveal evidence of unloading. Examples C and 9 (carbonate, and pH modifica- tion plus carbonate) performed well for the remainder of the test period, with each showing a gradual trend 00 with timi of further reduction in corrosion. At the termination of the study, Example 9, according to the S* S 20 present invention, which received carbonate supplemen- 0* tation plus pH adjustment, exhibited lead levels 92 percent below the control, while carbonate adjustment 0 0#9 alone (Example C) resulted in an.82 percent reduction. The continued trend of declining lead levels suggests 1 25 that over longer periods of time, even better perform- ance would occur. Best results were obtained through optimization of both pH and carbonate. Example 10; Corrosion Potential Measurements Corrosion potential measurements were performed on lead coupons under conditions of constant pH and carbonate concentration. In this experiment, zero corrosion was obtained at an imposed potential of -0.629 volts. Free potential was then monitored over a near 24 hour period, during which time the dissolved oxygen level was incremented at intervals, while pH and carbonate were held constant. The results are pre- sented in the following table and illustrated in Figure 7: TABLE 4 Time Potential Dissolved Units Volts Oxygen, mg/1 C/P(3) 1 -0.615 1.2 C 2 -0.605 2.2 C 3 -0.641 2.5 P 4 -0.658 4.4 P -0.671 7.5 P
Arbitrary units. Time unit 5 is less than 24 hours. 0COl Eo (for zero corrosion) 0.629 volts,
C active corrosion P passivation Carbonate alkalinity 200 mg/1 as CaCO 3 0 0 pH 8.0 0.06 throughout test period
Despite the increased oxygen levels, lead corrosion *0*
0C*( ceased less than halfway through the experimental a: period. Passivation was unusually rapid in this inst- ance, due to. the high supplemental carbonate level ii0 0.* employed. Examples 11-14'; Use of Zinc Orthophosphate In the absence of sufficient calcium carbonate hardness to protect unlined pipes, water purveyors occasionally employ proprietary corrosion control C. C
chemicals such as phosphate or silicate salts. The following tests were conducted as a means of comparison with the carbonate supplementation/pH control as described above. Duplicate coupon tests were performed with a zinc orthophosphate solution, with initial passivation at a chemical dosage of 3 mg/l as zinc'for one week, followed by incubation at 1. mg/i as zinc for one~and two weeks. The results are shown in the following tables:
#a a a. a a tat. a a a. a. a a a **Ot a a a *t a. a. at a, a a a
a. at a .4 Ot
a eta a aa*a a. ta a
Carbonate Example! Alkalinity, mg/l LTead, mg/l Sample, pH as CaCG 3 Soluble Totea
11/Boston Water Range 7.24-9.13 3.7-12.1 0.331-0.32 29.2-32.4 Average 7.9 0.31 30.8 12/Boston Water plus Zinc Orthopho sphate Range 6.21-8.72 5.0-11.7 0.30-0.47 35.4-42.0 Average 8.3 0.39 38.7
Percent Change +5.1 +24.2 +25.6
NOTE: Sample incubated in Boston water plus zinc solution at 3 mg/i as zinc for one week, followed by incubation in fresh Boston water with zinc solution added at 1 mg/i as zinc for one week.
00 00 00 SO 5 50 4 0* S 55 0 5 0 0 0 0 t tea 0 0 550 0 0 5 05 *0 55* 0 S~*0 C 0 0 @00 0 6* 0 0@ 0* SO 00 55 05 0* 004. 005 0 S
Carbonate Example/ Alkalinity, mg/i Lead, mg/i Sample, pH as CaCO3 Soluble Total
11/Boston Water Range 7.24-9.13 3.7-12.1 0.30-0.32 29.2-32.4 Average 7.9 0.31 30.8
12/Boston Water plus Zinc Orthophosphate Range 6.21-8.72 5.0-11.7 0.30-0.47 35.4-42.0 Average 8.3 0.39 38.7
Percent Change +5.1 +24.2 +25.6
NOTE: Sample incubated in Boston water plus zinc solution at 3 mg/i as zinc for one week, followed by incubation in fresh Boston water with zinc solution added at I mg/i as zinc for one week.
4 SO 0, 0 S S S S Soto 0 0 I- c
TABLE~ 5 (continued)
Carbonate Example/ Alkalinity, mg/l Lead, mg/I Sample pH as CaCO3 Soluble Total
13/Boston Water Range 6.56-6.69 13.3-15.8 0.27-0.33 0.80-1.38 Average 14.6 0.30 1.09
14/Boston Water plus Zinc Orthophosphate Range 6.52-6.82 13.3-15.8 0.23-0.72 0.46-1.57 Average 14.6 0.48 1.02
Percent Change 0.0 +60.0 -6.4
NOTE: Sample incubated in Boston water plus zinc solution at 3 lug/i as zinc for one week, followed by incubation in Boston water with zinc solution added at 1 mg/l as zinc for one week. Sample then transferred to fresh Boston water plus zinc solution at 1 mg/'l as zinc for one week incubation and sample analyzed.
0 00 0 0 0 0 0 ee U0 boo 0 a S 60 0O e 006 0 000 00 006 0 00 65 06 90 0 t 00 0*0 e0.e S 0
TABLE 5 (continued)
Carbonate Example/ Alkalinity, mg/l Lead, mg/1 Sample pH as CaC03 Soluble Total
13/Boston Water Range 6.56-6.69 13.3-15.8 0.27-0.33 0.80-1.38 Average -14.6 0.30 1.09
14/Boston Water plus Zinc Orthophosphate Range 6.52-6.82 13.3-15.8 0.23-0.72 0.46-1.57 Average -14.6 0.48 1.02
Percent Change -0.0 +60.0 -6.4
NOTE: Sample incubated in Boston water plus zinc solution at 3 mg/l as zinc for one week, followed by incubation in Boston water with zinc solution added at 1 mg/1 as zinc for one week. Sample then transferred to fresh Boston water plus zinc solution at 1 mg/l as zinc for one week incubation and sample analyzed.
0 5 0 S S S S O e 600 o 50 00 0. *0 55 r 0 000 0 00 a O :000
At the conclusion of the one week incubation, both ,Soluble and total lead were approximately 25 percent higher in the Boston water to which zinc orthophosphate .had been added than in the control water. After a fuzther week of incubation (in freshly prepared water), corrosion in the zinc solution resulted in a 60 percent increase in soluble lead, and a slight decrease in total lead as compared with the control. Lead corro- sion contcrol results are summarized in the following table.-
*4 ft., ft
ft. qe* 4.
ft. 4 0 0 Oft ft.., ft... ft .0 0 go 0ft Oft ft. ft
4m ft. ft ~00
*0 *0 ft.. ft
010ft t0 0O ft
P ft 4. 0 4,.
TABLE 6
Soluble (S) Percent Change or Total (T) Control Method in Lead Lead Reference
1. pH adjustment to pH1 8-8.5 Coupon Tests -72 Table 2 Pipe Tests -65 Figure 7 2. Carbonate adjustment to mg/l as CaCO 3 -82 Figure 7
3. pH plus carbonate adjustment Coupon Tests -96 Table 2 Pipe Tests -92 Figure 7 4. Zinc orthophosphate addition +24 to +60 Table -6 to +26
CO 00 00 00 00 a em 00 0 0e 0 60 0 0 a S 0 00 0 eca a *@o 0 0 U 000 0 *00 0 0 000 0 6 06 04 0 00 00 0* *6 000 0 S 6000 0~ *0 60 0000
TAB3LE 6
Soluble (S) Percent Change or Total (T) Control Method in Lead Lead Reference
1. pH adjustment to pH 8-8.5 Coupon Tests -72 Table 2 Pipe Tests -65 Figure 7 2. Carbonate adjustment to mg/I as CaCO 3 -82 Figure 7 3. pH plus carbonate adjustment Coupon Tests -96 Table 2 Pipe Tests -92 Figure 7 4. 1Zinc orthophosphate addition +24 to +60 Table -6 to +26
90 00 S US 50 05 0 0 5* *0 S C S S S 4 9 00 0 C 090 S 0 950 0 S S 555 5 5 005 S C C 599 5* S S 05 5 *g *0 S 650 0 .555 55 05 55 5550
The process of the present invention is con- veniently carried out using available water treatment and distribution equipment. Initially an analysis of the drinking water requiring treatment is made at the tap of the consumer. Several samples are taken, preferably from various locations throughout the system, and a water profile is obtained. Next, the amounts of carbonate and alkali source are selected and calculated to produce the desired passivation. This is accomplished according to the principles described above. Sodium bicarbonate is the preferred carbonate source and sodium hydroxide or lime is used to adjust the pH of the water as may be required. Once the quantity of sodium bicarbonate and 1 15 sodium hydroxide are determined, they are mixed and metered into the water supply at a predetermined rate. This is conveniently done at a municipal water treat- ment facility. In use, the water system distributes the carbonate-supplemental/pH controlled water through- out the system which is monitored. The amounts of sodium bicarbonate and sodium hydroxide are indepen- ::dently variable and are adjusted in accordance with the passivation that is achieved. As the above Oata demonstrate, among the methods for lead corrosion control reported in the literature and evaluated in this study, pH adjustment in low alkalinity waters is beneficial to a limited extent. Use of zinc orthophosphate results in no oreduction in lead corrosion, and there is evidence from our studies that increased corrosion may even result. Greatest reduction and control of lead corro- sion resulted through a combination of pH adjustment and carbonate supplementation. From the operational cost viewpoint, the optimum pH appears to be between and 8.5, depending upon the carbonate level, and a minimum carbonate alkalinity concentration of 20 mg/1 as CaCO 3 is indicated, although a pH within the range of about 7.5 and about 9.0 is fully acceptable. The carbonate alkalinity may be increased substantially. As may be required, at least initially, however, amounts in excess of about 50 mg/l as CaCO 3 are of little advantage and only add to the cost of the system. Proper control of both carbonate level and pH are essential to the establishment and maintenance of the protective coating. Alternative methods of estab- dO lishing the film are possible. One might employ an initial high carbonate dose to accelerate the formation 15 of the film, followed by lower maintenance dosages. A second alternative is to begin with low carbonate levels then gradually increase the carbonate dosage until positive results are obtained. In either instance, the formed protective film must be perma- 20 nently maintained, through carbonate addition and pH control. Termination of carbonate supplementation results in gradual reversion to the active corrosive condition.
*o ar
Claims (1)
1. A process for controlling corrosion in a potable water distribution system including lead-containing con- duits which comprises adding a water-soluble carbonate source to the drinking water distributed by said system in the amount required _o passivate the lead-containing conduits of said system and maintaining the pH of the pot- able waterwithinsaid system at a pH of 7.5 to
2. A process according to claim 1 wherein the carbon- ate concentration in the treated water is 15 mg. to 50 mg. I per liter, calculated as CaCO 3
S3. A process according to claim 1 or 2 wherein the pH S. is 8.0 to 0
0 4. A process according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the potable water passing through said pipe 0
has a carbonate alkalinity of no less than 20 mg/l. calculated as calcium carbonate.
ee
5. A process according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the passivation is brought about by form- ing and maintaining a coating of lead carbonate on the inside surfaces of the conduits.
a 6. A process according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the water-soluble carbonate source is sodium hydrogen carbonate.
7. A process according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the pH of the water is adjusted, if neces- sary, to 7.5 to 9.0 by addition of sodium hydroxide or calcium hydroxide.
1 1W
-26-
8. A process according to claim 1 substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of the Examples.
9. The invention hereinbefore described in all its new and useful aspects.
DATED THIS 7th DAY OF SEPTEMB3ER 1978. CHURCH DWIGHT CO., INC. By its Patent Ak-torneys: SANDERCOCK, SMITH BEADLE Fellows Institute of Patent 4 Attorneys of Australia.
'I.
ae S a a a 6*e S
e.g. a a 0@ a. S. a a. a *5*e
a S
we a. 0w a a S a
-0.4
a. 0.8 S a. aS S 1.2 a 0*S* a. -1.6 S. S
a
S a. S 2.4 L *5 -2 0 2 '4 6 8 10.' 12 14 16
pH Equilibrium Conditions for Lead Passivation, Corrosion and Immunity in Water.
02ry., 2. v
4 0 4. S 0 PASS IVAT ION ft
*4S* 0* S.
S. S S S 0 0.8
0* 6O S V 0.4 CORROS ION 6S SO 4
4 S COIRR- OSION 0.4
44 0 -0.8 1- S. S IMMUNITY 0@5 -1.2
0*54 S. '1.6 .5 0
CORROSION -2.4 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
PH Equilibrium Conditions at One Molar Carbonate Concentration for Lead Passivation.
S so. 00* *0 S. 55 0500 S 0* 5O S .0 0 0 SOs 5 0@5 S 00* S S *0 S 0 S 5* OS 55
OJs
W-3
0- Mv
(CT =0 -3.2 -7
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 pH Predicted Solubility of.Lead in the Absence and Presence of Carbonate. Line Represents Lead Hyd~oide Solubility at Zero Carbonate. Line (2) Represents Solubility at IO- Molar Carbonate.
S 00 0e CC 0 C C C S go* C eC 0 egg S gee C e.g C C Ore S C 0S C. Be C 0 S. go
je1
-3
(I CTO0
CT 1 l M -7
-9 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 pH Preilicted Solubility of Lead in the Absence and Presence of Carbonate. Line Represents Lead Hydioide Solubility at Zero Carbonate. Line (2) Represents Solubility at 1 Molar Carbonate.
,41.
INITIAL PH
0 PH= +I 0O eg. a 0O9s METAL TESTED a, 0e a. -LEAD ONLY 0* a. a LEAD COPPER a 0*eO 0O 0~O *9
a. -J a a 0
a w -L
a. 0* a a. 0* 9. I egg a -O .1 a.
0 0* S a 0*
40 60 so INITIAL CARBONATE ALKALINITY, MG/L AS COC0 3
Corrosion Results at Nine Days Incubation for Lead and Galvanic Lead-Copper Coupons. .Lead Concentra- tiona are for Soluble Lead.
e a *000 *0 OS 0 000 0 a0 000 0 0 S 000 0* 0 0 0 *5O 0 0 0* S 0O S 000 S. S 0 00 5* t~
INITIAL ()INITIAL CARBONATE CON CE NTRATI ON, MG/L AS CcCO 3
0. 1
0.0 NINE-DAY RESULTS THIRTY-DAY RESULTS
Compariso~n of Results at Nine and Thirty Days Exposure on Lead Coupons. Lead Conc~'ntrations are for Soluble Lead.
*6 0:.0 SC.. *5 Ce SC £005 0 S9 o C S eeC 65 6 J 0*e 000 S S S so* 6 C C S C V 4* 0 C. C. OC S.
INITIAL pI-= 7 .0 ()INITIAL CARBONATE CONCENTRATION, MG/L AS CaCCO3
NINE-DAY RESULTS THIRTY-DAY RESULTS
Comparison of Results at Nine and Thirty Days Exposure on Lead Coupons. Lead concentrations are for Soluble ',ead.
__A3 .g O000 NaOH ADDED TO PH
20 MG/L BICARB ONLY _j
0 0* 0 o 100 X-X-X 20 MG/L BICARB pH 0I S ADJUSTMENT TO z 0000 0 0* *0 00 UNLOADING OF NON-ADHERENT *0 0 0 Pb(OH) 2 FILM .0 0 U 0000
*000
SO S.
08 00 0 S z 0
a 4
'U
06 0 0 *0 o04 U 0@ So. 00
0 0000 00 00 0
00 10 20 30 40 50 0 a. TIME AFTER START OF EXPERIMENT, DAYS
Results of Lead Pipe Corrosion Tests. Lead Pipe Segments Were Refilled Daily with indicated Test Waters. Sodium Bicarbonate Levels are 20 mg/l as Equivalent Calcium Carbonate.
0*P0 00 05 0S 0000 0 00 00 0 0 000 0 000 000 0 0 000 S 0 00 0 00 0 00 00 00 0. 00
~0 .0
U)
0.64
0-0.64 cz
1 2 3 4 TIME UNITS (ARBITRARY) Corrosion Potential Measurements on Lead over 24 Hours at Constant pH and Carbonate Alkalinity.
S *SS S 55 S S S 5S S 5* S S 5 OSS S 50 5 S 0 0 0 st 00 S S S 55 5 0 S. S S 5@ 05
0- 0.60
I-
0 0.64 z 0 0-0.66
0 U 12 3 4
TIME UNITS (ARBiTRARY) WY- Corrosion Potential Measurements on Lead over 24 Hours at Constant PH and Carbonate Alkalinity.
*IJ:
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| US90728078A | 1978-05-18 | 1978-05-18 |
Publications (1)
| Publication Number | Publication Date |
|---|---|
| AU3969578A true AU3969578A (en) | 1980-03-13 |
Family
ID=25423822
Family Applications (1)
| Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| AU39695/78A Pending AU3969578A (en) | 1978-05-18 | 1978-09-08 | Corrosion control process |
Country Status (4)
| Country | Link |
|---|---|
| JP (1) | JPS54150336A (en) |
| AU (1) | AU3969578A (en) |
| BE (1) | BE869847A (en) |
| DE (1) | DE2823870A1 (en) |
Families Citing this family (3)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IL73198A (en) * | 1984-10-09 | 1988-01-31 | Technion Res & Dev Foundation | Method for rapid controlled coating of the inner surfaces of pipes with a tenacious calcite lining |
| DE102017107529A1 (en) * | 2017-04-07 | 2018-10-11 | Lisa Dräxlmaier GmbH | Process for corrosion inhibition of metals and tempering system for a metallic tool |
| JP7053277B2 (en) * | 2018-01-10 | 2022-04-12 | 大成建設株式会社 | Galvanized steel pipe |
-
1978
- 1978-05-31 DE DE19782823870 patent/DE2823870A1/en not_active Withdrawn
- 1978-08-18 BE BE189969A patent/BE869847A/en unknown
- 1978-09-08 AU AU39695/78A patent/AU3969578A/en active Pending
- 1978-11-06 JP JP13663378A patent/JPS54150336A/en active Pending
Also Published As
| Publication number | Publication date |
|---|---|
| BE869847A (en) | 1979-02-19 |
| JPS54150336A (en) | 1979-11-26 |
| DE2823870A1 (en) | 1979-11-22 |
Similar Documents
| Publication | Publication Date | Title |
|---|---|---|
| GB2036069B (en) | Isomerization process | |
| JPS5587218A (en) | Inputtoutput controller | |
| GB2012968B (en) | Process control system | |
| JPS54161207A (en) | Controller | |
| DE2965609D1 (en) | Self-supervising process control system | |
| PH19618A (en) | Process for preparing -2-pyrrolidone | |
| JPS5544698A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS5566738A (en) | Controller | |
| GB2035879B (en) | Injetion moilding control | |
| GB2015711B (en) | Process heater | |
| GB2023179B (en) | Metal electrposition process | |
| JPS54119205A (en) | Controller | |
| GB2018276A (en) | Isomerization process | |
| JPS5563001A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS5523756A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS5547860A (en) | Germmkilling process | |
| JPS54139950A (en) | Coating method | |
| JPS5513598A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS5543284A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS55109443A (en) | Microocapsulizing process | |
| JPS54127934A (en) | Coating process | |
| JPS54130639A (en) | Coating method | |
| JPS54121634A (en) | Controller | |
| JPS54136733A (en) | Oillfence extending method | |
| JPS5515600A (en) | Process controller |